Whether you gravitate towards good old vanilla, a soft serve swirl, or a banana split, Northeast Dutchess County has some of the best spots to stop by and indulge in a delicious frozen treat. From classic creameries to roadside delights, read on for our tried and tested picks of the top scoop spots in the area.
1. Kelly’s Creamery
Kelly’s Creamery is so much more than a plain old ice cream spot. While their extensive selection of handcrafted artisanal ice cream, italian ice, and soft serve is incomparable, they also boast a food truck and an 18-hole mini golf course. Their ‘pup cups’ for your four legged bestie is served with a homemade frozen peanut butter and vanilla ice cream paw treat which makes it just as cute as it is yummy for your pup!
3202 NY-22, Dover Plains, 845-442-9366, kellyscreamerykht.com
2. Zoe’s Ice Cream Barn
Using only Hudson Valley Fresh dairy products, Zoe’s Ice Cream Barn serves ice cream “from cow to cone in three days.” Alongside their mouthwatering ice cream, they offer burgers, hot dogs, sandwiches, salads, and more…all in an atmospheric barn-like setting.
1181 State Rte 55, Lagrangeville, 845-454-7108, zoesicecreambarn.com
3. Candy O’s Sweet Shop
Candy O’s is well known for their irresistible candy and chocolate selection. However, they offer a vast selection of Jane’s Ice Cream flavors. Jane’s is made locally in Kingston, NY!
28 Main St, Millerton, 518-592-1600, candy-os.com
4. The Grand Shack at Four Brothers Pizza Inn
When you think of Four Brothers Pizza, you may think of famous pizza, greek salads, or drive-in movie theater. However, tucked behind the main restaurant is their “Grand Shack.” From classic cones to specialty sundaes to pup cups, they offer some of the best ice cream in the area! Their soft serve is not just any soft serve, but custard-based to make it extra creamy, rich, and delicious!
4957 NY-22, Amenia, 845-373-8178, playeatdrink.com
5. Quattro Farm Store
A local favorite, Quattro Farm Store is most famous for its butcher, groceries, and hunting supplies. However, their soft serve ice cream is to die for! Check out their ice cream window or head inside for a sweet treat.
2251 US-44, Pleasant Valley, 845-635-2018
6. Utterly Delicious
Utterly Delicious has a flavor for everyone! Their menu is vast, offering both hard and soft serve options. They are most famous for their ice cream cakes, perfect for any occasion!
1898 US-44, Pleasant Valley, 845-723-4261
7. Fudgy’s Ice Cream
Fudgy’s is a roadside favorite for ice cream. They have something for everyone, offering a wide variety of hard and soft ice cream flavors, shakes, and yogurts. They offer gluten and sugar free options, as well.
4789 NY-22, Amenia, 845-373-8291
8. Fortunes Ice Cream
Fresh, seasonal, quality ice cream in the heart of Tivoli. Locally-made premium flavors.
55 Broadway, Tivoli, NY 12583. (845) 757-2899
9. Creams & Crumbs
Hard scoops and soft serve ice cream. Rotating monthly homemade cookies. Open late night year round with savory snacks.
9 E. Main Street, Pawling @creamsandcrumbs
10. Normby Creamery
Small-batch ice cream shop that makes their own flavors using plant-based colors. Using local suppliers, they make their creamy and simple ice cream treats with a focus on gluten-free and all natural inclusions.
3 Memorial Ave. Pawling. normbycreamery.com
11. Flaming Su’gar
Jamaican-style vegan food and a variety of delicious ice cream treats–including a standout red velvet flavor.
43 Violet Ave. Poughkeepsie
12. Joe’s Dairy Bar & Grill
Open year round for milkshakes, sundaes, and specialty cakes, and more.
550 Route 82, Hopewell Junction joesdairybarandgrill.com
13. Fishkill Creamery
Quaint ice cream shop offering bubble tea, milkshakes, and a wide range of flavors, including vegan options.
1042 Main Street, Fishkill fishkillcreamery.com